Nanometre-thick alumina coatings deposited by ALD on metals : a comparative electrochemical and surface analysis study of corrosion properties

Author
Shadi Mirhashemihaghighi
Year
2015
Abstract & Cover

In this work, nanometre-thick (10 to 50 nm) coatings were grown by atomic layer deposition (ALD) on copper and aluminium substrates for improvement of the corrosion protection. TMA and water were used as precursors for ALD deposition of alumina at 250°C. The corrosion protection properties were studied by combination of electrochemical (LSV and EIS) and surface analysis (ToF-SIMS depth profiling and surface imaging). Microscopy techniques (AFM and SEM) were used as additional methods. Using ToF-SIMS elemental depth profiling, three regions, the bulk coating region, the interfacial region and the substrate region were identified and characterized. Independent of the film thickness and the substrate material, the alumina coating had constant in depth stoichiometry. Carbonaceous and hydroxyl fragments were always present in the bulk of the coating, as a result of partially unreacted precursors. Chlorine was also detected in the coating due to the high sensitivity of ToF-SIMS, and its origin was trace (less than 1%) chlorine contamination of the TMA precursor. OH- , C- and Cl- ions profiles peaks at the extreme surface of the coating and at the coating/substrate interface were attributed to contamination from the ambient after and before the coating deposition. Hydroxyl contamination was always decreasing with increased deposited coating thickness, owing to the fact that increasing deposition time promotes the removal of hydroxyl fragments by completing the reactions of deposition. A lower hydroxyl level of the coating was linked to a higher density and a lower porosity confirmed with electrochemical tests. In the case of copper, phosphorus (from elctropolishing and pre-treatment) and sulphur (segregating from bulk copper) were other contaminants detected at the interface. For both aluminium and copper substrates, the coating/substrate interface exhibited the presence of an interfacial native/spurious oxide. In the case of copper, only traces of copper oxide were present and the oxide formed most likely a discontinuous layer. For the aluminium on the contrary, the oxide contribution to the interfacial region was noticeable and its composition, similar to the one of the ALD coating, complicated the interpretation of the depth profiles. The electrochemical analysis done in 0.5 M NaCl aqueous solution evidenced a substantial improvement of the corrosion properties of electropolished copper substrate coated with ALD alumina. This improvement was quantified using porosity calculations based on the comparison of anodic currents, polarization and charge transfer resistances and double layer capacitances obtained from LSV and EIS data, employing four different methods and leading to results with excellent agreement. Application of these methods was established based on the high dielectric properties of ALD alumina leading to the corrosion of the substrate only via residual pinholes and/or channel defects through the coating, connecting the substrate to the electrolyte, as evidenced by the same shape of LSV polarization curves for the bare and coated samples. The enhancement of polarization resistance and reduction of anodic current reached four orders of magnitude for the 50 nm coating, limiting the uncoated surface fraction to ~0.01%. The decrease of the measured porosity with increasing coating thickness was in agreement with the trend of hydroxyl contamination observed by ToF-SIMS. The low porosity also obtained for the thinner (10 nm) coating, less than 1%, confirmed ALD alumina as an excellent ultrathin coating for the corrosion protection of copper. EIS experiments done at OCP and adoption of a proper equivalent circuit model shed more light on the corrosion mechanisms. In spite of observing only one time constant for the coated electropolished copper samples, the results were fitted also with an equivalent circuit model including separate time constants for the coating and the substrate. Using such circuit model, significantly high Rpore values were obtained, indicating a significantly lower cross section area of the channel defects in the bulk of the coating in comparison with the interface where the coating is attached to the substrate. This difference was attributed to the fast trenching of the substrate where it is attached to the coating leading to the higher opening of the channel defects at the bottom where they meet the susbtrate. The study done in Chapter IV ‎ , on the effect of the interfacial copper oxide under the coating, confirmed the appropriate choice of a pre-treatment for the removal of the native oxide before the coating deposition done in ‎Chapter III. Lower corrosion protection for the coating on a substrate without pre-treatment was attributed to the presence of higher amount of Cu(I) sites at the bottom of the channel defects, favouring oxygen reduction. Higher corrosion of the substrate led to higher dissolution of the coating both at the interface and in the bulk coating, confirmed by Rpore and Rct values. However an initial more defective growth of the coating on a substrate without pre-treatment was also supported by the higher OH- level in the bulk of the coating and higher C- level at the interface. More localized corrosion occured on the coated substrate without pre-treatment as shown by the detection of pits with ToF-SIMS, which was not the case for the pre-treated specimen. Modification of the interfacial oxide by pre-treatment of the copper substrate before ALD deposition was thus shown to have a positive effect on the corrosion resistance of the coated samples. Topographical alteration of the copper surface by annealing for further reduction of surface asperities for a better performance of the ALD coatings was studied in ‎Chapter V. However, the surface preparation by annealing was shown to lead to poor adhesion properties of the coating. Smoothening of the substrate was implied from the ToF-SIMS profiles and confirmed from AFM images and related roughness calculations. Annealing was also effective in reducing the interfacial C- and Cl- contamination. However, the higher intensity of the CuO2 - and OH- ions on the annealed coated substrates suggested coating detachment for the pristine samples, which was further confirmed with electrochemical measurements as well as ToF-SIMS and SEM imaging on pristine samples. The anodic shift of corrosion potential and increase of cathodic Tafel slopes for annealed coated samples in comparison with the electropolished ones was attributed to the high exposure of interfacial copper oxide to the electrolyte for these samples, in agreement with the ToF-SIMS data. Apart from the initially high porosity values obtained from EIS, the significant increase of the porosity obtained from LSV denoted coating detachment in the electrolyte, which was further confirmed with SEM imaging and ToF-SIMS chemical mapping on polarized samples. Although on electropolished substrate the best performance was obtained for the thickest coating, it showed the worse performance on the annealed substrate. Apart from mechanical effects, the poor performance for the thickest coating was also attributed to higher local increase of pH for a thicker coating leading to enhancement of dissolution of alumina and delamination of the coating. In spite of high sealing property of ALD alumina on electropolished copper substrate, the studies presented in Chapter VI ‎ revealed its low durability for longer immersion times. Initial resistance and capacitance values measured after 30 min immersion revealed an increase of the coating porosity of one order of magnitude and a decrease of 9.69 × 10-4 nm.h -1 in thickness as a result of atmospheric corrosion. The decrease in coating thickness accelerated in the electrolyte to 0.9 nm.h -1 even though its porosity remained unchanged. Coating thickness decrease was confirmed from ToF-SIMS depth profiling and the calculated value was in good agreement with EIS. The absence of marked change in the coating matrix and no notable corrosion of the substrate observed on ToF-SIMS depth profiles were in agreement with unchanged porosity calculated from EIS. Internodular (between two adjacant nodules) preferential dissolution of the coating at nanometric scale was revealed and measured from AFM images. The study of ALD alumina on aluminium substrate presented in the last chapter showed the successful growth of the coating also on Al substrate. Investigation of its corrosion properties revealed significant improvement of the corrosion protection. Lower porosities were obtained for 10 and 20 nm coatings on Al susbtrate than on copper, implying a better coating performance on Al substrate. The significant decrease of the passive current for all coating thicknesses demonstrated the good sealing property, however 10 nm did not show sufficient barrier properties to increase the pitting potential. Considering the similar porosity obtained for the 20 and 50 nm coatings, and the increase of the pitting potential in both cases (slightly higher for the latter one), and considering the cathodic shift of the corrosion potential for the 50 nm coating, 20 nm seemed to be the most appropriate choice. Therefore, the best coating performance was obtained with a lower coating thickness on Al than on copper, which is considered highly beneficial. The long delay between the substrate preparation and the coating deposition in addition to the high roughness of the Al substrate in comparison with the Cu substrate, complicated the interpretation of EIS results coming from the 3D distribution of time constants in the interfacial oxide. The present thesis work was a fundamental research on the growth of ALD alumina on pure copper and aluminium and the corrosion protection on these two metals. The satisfactory results obtained on electropolished copper and polished aluminium, confirm ALD alumina as a promising candidate for corrosion protection of Al-Cu alloys. Regarding the excellent sealing properties of ALD alumina, it is proposed in combination with more chemically stable ALD coatings in mixture and laminates for corrosion protection of high precision devices where Al and Cu are used. Future perspective of the present study would be the investigation of corrosion protection of ALD alumina on Al-Cu alloys and in combination with more chemically stable ALD coatings, such as TiO2 or Ta2O5.

Source of Information
Fabien Piallat
University
Université Pierre et Marie Curie - Paris VI
(Paris, France)
External Link
Read Thesis
LinkedIn
linkedin invite